375 Commack Rd., Deer Park, NY Practicing since 1994 Free initial consultation Same-day walk-ins welcome
Speak with Beth: (631) 595-5691
Call Beth Free Consultation
Mother and young daughter walking hand in hand on an autumn park path
Children and Family Court

Child custody lawyer for Long Island parents

A child custody lawyer should start by learning how your family actually works, then build the case around your child's daily life. Beth A. Rosenthal has represented parents in custody and visitation matters since 1994, in Suffolk County Family Court and in Supreme Court divorce cases.

  • You speak directly with Beth
  • Free initial consultation
  • Payment plans available
Beth A. Rosenthal, family law attorney in Deer Park, NY
Beth A. RosenthalYour lawyer, start to finish

Beth has been appointed by the court to represent children as attorney for the child, so she knows how judges weigh a child's best interests from the child's side of the case.

  • Appointed attorney for the child
  • Practicing since 1994
  • Family Court and Supreme Court
Talk with Beth

Reviewed by Beth A. Rosenthal, Esq. · Updated October 2026

How custody is decided

Every custody decision turns on your child's best interests

New York has no automatic preference for mothers or fathers. A judge deciding custody asks which arrangement serves the child best and looks at the whole family to answer it. The same standard applies whether the case starts as a Family Court petition or as part of a divorce, and again if a parent later asks to change the order.

In practice, courts look at who has handled the day-to-day care, the stability of each home, each parent's schedule and ability to meet the child's needs, and whether each parent supports the child's relationship with the other. A child's own wishes can count, with more weight as the child grows older and more mature. Allegations of domestic violence must be considered, and Beth handles orders of protection when they are part of the case.

Custody is usually one piece of a larger set of issues: support, the house, sometimes a divorce. The full list of practice areas shows how the pieces connect.

  • Daily caregiving
  • Stability of each home
  • Support for the other parent
  • The child's wishes
  • Safety
Child's drawing of a family on a refrigerator next to a school schedule
Since1994
Legal and physical custody

Two kinds of custody, two ways to share them

Every custody order answers two separate questions. Legal custody covers the major decisions in a child's life: education, health care and religion. Physical custody, also called residential custody, covers where the child lives most of the time. Either one can be joint or sole, which gives four basic combinations. Open any square to see what it means day to day.

Want to know how a judge is likely to see your custody situation? Talk it through with Beth.

Parenting schedules

Parenting time works when the schedule is specific

Visitation is the older word for parenting time: the schedule a child keeps with each parent. A good order spells out the regular weeks, holidays, school breaks, birthdays and summer, plus who handles pickups and where handoffs happen. Vague orders invite arguments. Specific ones give children a routine they can count on.

When there are real safety concerns, a court can order supervised parenting time or set other conditions.

Parent AParent BMidweek evening visit

Weekends alternate between homes, with a midweek evening visit. The child keeps one school-week base.

Which court hears it

Family Court, Supreme Court, and what comes after

Suffolk County Family Court

If you are not getting divorced, custody starts with a petition in Family Court. That covers parents who never married and married parents who live apart without a divorce case. Family Court also hears child support, paternity and family offense petitions, so related issues often move through the same courthouse together.

New York State Supreme Court

Once a divorce is filed, custody is decided inside the divorce case in Supreme Court. The divorce cannot be granted until custody, support and property are resolved, by agreement or by the judge. If you are at that stage, start with divorce and separation.

Changing an order later

Custody orders are not frozen. A parent can ask the court to modify one by showing a change in circumstances since it was made, and that a new arrangement would be better for the child. A new work schedule, a child's changing needs, or a parent who keeps ignoring the order can all be grounds. When the other parent simply stops following the order, enforcement is a separate petition.

Moving with your child

A move that would make the current schedule unworkable generally needs either the other parent's agreement in writing or the court's permission. The judge weighs the reasons for the move, its effect on the child's relationship with the other parent, and whether a new schedule can keep that relationship real. Moving first and asking later puts a parent in a weak position.

Children and Family Court services

Find the part of your case that comes next

Custody rarely stands alone. Choose the situation closest to yours to see where it usually starts, what to bring, and which page covers it in depth.

Likely fit
Child support and paternity

Support follows New York's Child Support Standards Act and can be decided in the same Family Court case as custody. If paternity has never been established, that comes first, by Acknowledgment of Paternity or a petition with genetic testing.

Child support and paternity
  • Where it startsA support petition in Family Court, or a support claim inside a divorce.
  • What to bringYour last tax return, recent pay stubs, and child care and insurance receipts.
Before you file

What to start keeping track of now

Custody cases turn on facts, and the parent with organized, dated records is easier to believe. Start now, even if nothing has been filed. Keep the case off social media.

01
A parenting calendar

Who handled pickups, overnights, doctor visits and school events, written down as it happens.

02
Messages with the other parent

Texts and emails about the children. Keep them civil, because a judge may read every one.

03
School and medical records

Report cards, attendance, teacher notes, and who brings the child to appointments.

04
Missed or late visits

Dates and times when parenting time did not happen as planned, and the reason given.

05
Your work schedule

Hours, shifts and flexibility, plus the child care you rely on while you work.

06
Any safety concerns

Police reports, orders of protection or CPS contact. Bring these to the first meeting.

How Beth handles custody

Settlement first, court if needed

A parenting plan both parents helped write usually holds up better than one handed down by a judge, and it costs less to reach. Beth builds the plan around the facts: school, work schedules, routines, and what has gone wrong. From there she works toward a plan the other side can accept, through negotiation or mediation where it fits.

When the other parent will not be reasonable, or a child's safety is at stake, she prepares the case for a hearing and presents it in court. She has long working relationships with the local courts.

You speak directly with Beth about your case.

Beth is a kind and compassionate person but a no nonsense lawyer in the court room. She is the kind of person you want by your side. She doesn't play games and will tell you how it is and what you should expect. Her Staff is friendly and professional. I have and would recommend her to anyone I talk to.
Beth V. Google review
Questions

Custody questions parents ask first

Short answers to what comes up most in a first meeting. Your own facts will change the details, and the free consultation covers them.

Do mothers get custody more often in New York?

New York law does not favor either parent because of gender. The judge looks at the child's best interests, including who has handled daily care and which home offers more stability. A custody lawyer helps you show the court the parenting you already do.

At what age can my child choose where to live?

There is no set age in New York when a child gets to decide. Judges give a child's wishes more weight as the child gets older and more mature, but those wishes are one factor among several. Children are usually heard through an attorney appointed for the child rather than by testifying in open court.

Can we agree on custody without a court fight?

Yes. Parents can work out a parenting plan through negotiation or mediation and then submit it to the court so it becomes an order. That last step matters, because an informal agreement cannot be enforced if one parent stops following it.

How long does a custody case take in Suffolk County?

It depends mostly on whether the parents reach an agreement. An agreed schedule can be in place far sooner than a case that needs a hearing, and the court can issue a temporary order while the case is pending. Beth will give you a straight read on timing at the first consultation.

What does it cost to hire a custody lawyer?

Your first consultation with Beth as your custody lawyer is free, and payment plans are available. The total depends on whether the case settles or goes to a hearing, which is one reason she works toward an agreement first. Ask about fees at the first meeting so you know what to expect.

Free initial consultation

Talk to Beth before the next court date

Whether you have been served with a custody petition or need to file one, a free consultation tells you which court, which petition and what to bring.

Free initial consultation
Questions about divorce, custody or support? Talk to Beth.

Call the Deer Park office or request a consultation. You speak directly with Beth, and payment plans are available.

Touro Law School graduate Practicing since 1994 Free initial consultation Payment plans available