Hiring a divorce lawyer in Central Islip, NY, usually means hiring someone who will stand with you on Carleton Avenue, because that is where most Suffolk divorces and many Family Court cases are heard. Beth Rosenthal has handled those cases since 1994 from her Deer Park office at 375 Commack Road, and she works with you herself from the first call.
Central Islip clients reach Beth's Deer Park office by the Southern State west to Deer Park Avenue, or by train two stops west, past Brentwood.
One family can have papers in more than one courtroom on Carleton Avenue at the same time: a divorce in Supreme Court, say, and a family offense petition in Family Court. Pick a court to see what it handles, who decides or brings the case, and one practical note for the day you go.
A Central Islip divorce is filed in New York State Supreme Court, and the no-fault ground only asks that the marriage has been irretrievably broken for at least six months. The harder work is everything the judgment has to settle first: property and debt, maintenance and child support, and custody with a parenting schedule. For many couples the largest asset is the home. If it was bought after the wedding, New York usually treats it as marital, even when only one spouse signed the mortgage.
When spouses cannot agree, the case becomes contested: financial disclosure, a preliminary conference and, if talks fail, a trial in the Floyd building. A contested divorce lawyer prepares for that trial while still pressing for a settlement, which can come at any stage.
Without a divorce, a parent's custody or support petition goes to Family Court. Within one, Supreme Court decides the same questions. The same standards apply in both, and the child custody page explains how judges weigh them.
A signed agreement can keep most of a Central Islip couple's case out of the courtrooms on Carleton Avenue. Spouses who already agree can sign a separation agreement covering support, custody and property, and after living apart under it for one year, either spouse can convert it to a divorce. Couples who need help reaching terms can work with a neutral mediator and still have a lawyer of their own review what they sign.
An agreement holds only if it is in writing, signed and acknowledged like a deed. The agreements and planning page covers prenups, postnups and separation agreements, and Beth also reviews drafts written by the other side's lawyer.
By the Expressway, follow Carleton Avenue north, where it turns into Wheeler Road, to Exit 56, then drive west to Exit 51 and go south on Deer Park Avenue to Commack Road. By the parkway, ride the Southern State west from Exit 43A to Exit 39 and take Deer Park Avenue north into Deer Park.
By train, Central Islip station sits at Suffolk Avenue and Lowell Avenue on the Ronkonkoma Branch, and Deer Park station is a short drive from the office. From the streets around Suffolk Avenue and Carleton Avenue, or from Islandia and Hauppauge next door, the same routes apply.
Yes. The court system lists Suffolk County Transit's 3C bus as serving the court complex, and that route also stops at Central Islip station on the LIRR. Before the date, ask your divorce lawyer which building and courtroom your papers name, so you go straight there.
No. A criminal case in District Court is about the charges. Custody is a separate question, decided on the children's best interests. An order of protection from either case can still limit contact and exchanges, so a divorce lawyer handling custody needs a copy of it.
The court system says it can be easier to get a temporary order in Family Court, where you file the petition yourself and the standard of proof is lower than in criminal court. In Central Islip that petition goes before a Family Court judge on Carleton Avenue. If you are not safe right now, call 911 before anything else.
Whether the summons came from Family Court or your spouse filed for divorce in Supreme Court, Beth will go through it with you and say plainly what comes next.
Call the Deer Park office or request a consultation. You speak directly with Beth, and payment plans are available.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The information on this website is general and is not legal advice for any particular situation. Contacting the office through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship.