375 Commack Rd., Deer Park, NY Practicing since 1994 Free initial consultation Same-day walk-ins welcome
Speak with Beth: (631) 595-5691
Call Beth Free Consultation
Central Islip, Town of Islip

Divorce lawyer in Central Islip, NY, where Suffolk family cases are heard

Hiring a divorce lawyer in Central Islip, NY, usually means hiring someone who will stand with you on Carleton Avenue, because that is where most Suffolk divorces and many Family Court cases are heard. Beth Rosenthal has handled those cases since 1994 from her Deer Park office at 375 Commack Road, and she works with you herself from the first call.

  • Practicing since 1994
  • Free initial consultation
Three courts, one address
1
Family CourtCustody, support and paternity petitions when no divorce is pending, and family offense petitions at any time.
2
Supreme CourtThe Marquette L. Floyd Supreme Court Building, home of the matrimonial parts that hear divorce and separation cases.
3
District CourtIts domestic violence part takes the criminal cases that police or the District Attorney bring.
All three list the same address: 400 Carleton Avenue, Central Islip, NY 11722.
Beth A. Rosenthal, family law attorney in Deer Park, NY

Central Islip clients reach Beth's Deer Park office by the Southern State west to Deer Park Avenue, or by train two stops west, past Brentwood.

Reviewed by Beth A. Rosenthal, Esq. · Updated October 2026
Court by court

Which Central Islip court hears which part of a family case

One family can have papers in more than one courtroom on Carleton Avenue at the same time: a divorce in Supreme Court, say, and a family offense petition in Family Court. Pick a court to see what it handles, who decides or brings the case, and one practical note for the day you go.

Suffolk County Family Court
Cases between parents and family members
  • What it hearsCustody and visitation, child support, paternity and neglect cases when no divorce is pending, and family offense petitions even while a divorce is open.
  • Who decidesA Family Court judge. Support and paternity petitions usually go before a Support Magistrate first.
  • Before you leave homeTwo locations
    Suffolk's Family Court also sits in Riverhead, so check the summons or petition for the building named on it.
How Family Court cases work
Divorce in Central Islip

When the house and the schedule are both in dispute

A Central Islip divorce is filed in New York State Supreme Court, and the no-fault ground only asks that the marriage has been irretrievably broken for at least six months. The harder work is everything the judgment has to settle first: property and debt, maintenance and child support, and custody with a parenting schedule. For many couples the largest asset is the home. If it was bought after the wedding, New York usually treats it as marital, even when only one spouse signed the mortgage.

When spouses cannot agree, the case becomes contested: financial disclosure, a preliminary conference and, if talks fail, a trial in the Floyd building. A contested divorce lawyer prepares for that trial while still pressing for a settlement, which can come at any stage.

  • Property and debt
  • Maintenance
  • Child support
  • Custody and parenting time
Custody, support and Family Court

Children, schools and support in a Central Islip case

Without a divorce, a parent's custody or support petition goes to Family Court. Within one, Supreme Court decides the same questions. The same standards apply in both, and the child custody page explains how judges weigh them.

  1. 01
    The school district
    Central Islip UFSD runs the hamlet's public schools and also takes in parts of Islandia and Ronkonkoma. Confirm each parent's district before agreeing where the children will live, since a move can mean a new school.
  2. 02
    Weekday parenting time
    Weekday time usually follows work hours and the school day. A plan that names who covers pickups, late nights and school breaks heads off arguments later.
  3. 03
    Support by formula
    New York sets basic child support as a percentage of combined parental income, shared by what each parent earns, with child care and health insurance costs added on.
  4. 04
    When safety is part of it
    If anyone is in immediate danger, call 911. Beth handles orders of protection when domestic violence is part of a case, and an order's terms can change how exchanges happen.
Agreements and planning

Settling on paper instead of in a courtroom

A signed agreement can keep most of a Central Islip couple's case out of the courtrooms on Carleton Avenue. Spouses who already agree can sign a separation agreement covering support, custody and property, and after living apart under it for one year, either spouse can convert it to a divorce. Couples who need help reaching terms can work with a neutral mediator and still have a lawyer of their own review what they sign.

An agreement holds only if it is in writing, signed and acknowledged like a deed. The agreements and planning page covers prenups, postnups and separation agreements, and Beth also reviews drafts written by the other side's lawyer.

Before you sign anything
  • Your first consultation is free
  • You meet with Beth, not a stand-in
  • Payment plans are available
  • Walk in the same day at 375 Commack Rd., Suite 200
Central Islip to Deer Park

Three ways from Central Islip to Commack Road

By the Expressway, follow Carleton Avenue north, where it turns into Wheeler Road, to Exit 56, then drive west to Exit 51 and go south on Deer Park Avenue to Commack Road. By the parkway, ride the Southern State west from Exit 43A to Exit 39 and take Deer Park Avenue north into Deer Park.

By train, Central Islip station sits at Suffolk Avenue and Lowell Avenue on the Ronkonkoma Branch, and Deer Park station is a short drive from the office. From the streets around Suffolk Avenue and Carleton Avenue, or from Islandia and Hauppauge next door, the same routes apply.

  • Brentwood
  • Islip Terrace
  • Ronkonkoma
  • Islip
See the Suffolk County service area
Central Islip, NY
Central Islip questions

What Central Islip clients ask about the courts

Central Islip, NY

Have papers from Carleton Avenue? Bring them to Commack Road

Whether the summons came from Family Court or your spouse filed for divorce in Supreme Court, Beth will go through it with you and say plainly what comes next.

Free initial consultation
Questions about divorce, custody or support? Talk to Beth.

Call the Deer Park office or request a consultation. You speak directly with Beth, and payment plans are available.

Touro Law School graduate Practicing since 1994 Free initial consultation Payment plans available