Can address
Property, debt and support between the two of you, along with estate rights. The terms can be narrow, covering a single account, or reach across everything you own.
Married couples on Long Island hire a postnuptial agreement lawyer when something in the marriage has changed and they want the money side settled on paper. Beth A. Rosenthal, practicing since 1994, drafts postnups for one spouse and reviews drafts that come from the other spouse's lawyer.
Signed after the wedding
Beth represents one spouse in a postnup, drafting the agreement or reviewing the other side's draft, and checks the disclosure and signing formalities a New York court looks for if the agreement is ever challenged.
Spouses sign a postnuptial agreement after the wedding, sometimes years into the marriage. In it, they decide which property belongs to one of them alone, how marital property and debt would be split, and what spousal maintenance would look like if the marriage ever ended. New York's statute treats agreements made before and during a marriage alike, so a postnup has to meet the standards a prenup does.
The difference is timing and purpose. A prenuptial agreement is signed before the wedding. A separation agreement is for spouses who are living apart. A postnup is for two people who intend to stay together and want one or more financial questions answered now. It is one of several documents in Beth's family agreements and planning work.
New York lets spouses set their own financial terms. Anything involving the children is measured against rules that a private contract cannot override.
Property, debt and support between the two of you, along with estate rights. The terms can be narrow, covering a single account, or reach across everything you own.
If custody or parenting time is ever in dispute, the court decides it on the children's best interests at that time, whatever the agreement says. Any child support terms are checked against the Child Support Standards Act.
Most couples come to a postnup for one of these five reasons, and each one changes what the agreement needs to say and which papers to gather.
Your reason for wanting a postnup shapes every clause. Talk it over with Beth before a first draft exists.
A postnup signed while the marriage is calm is far easier to defend than one signed in the middle of a crisis or under a deadline. Both spouses need room to gather records, read each draft and ask questions before anything is final.
If a draft has already arrived from your spouse's lawyer, do not sign it on the spot. Beth goes through it clause by clause with you, compares the attached disclosure to what you know about the finances, and marks what to push back on.
Both are made during the marriage and follow the same formal rules. One plans for a future that may never arrive. The other governs a marriage that has already come apart.
| Question | Postnuptial agreement | Separation agreement |
|---|---|---|
| Your living situation | Married and living together, planning to stay that way. | Married but living apart, or about to be. |
| What it covers | Property, debt, maintenance and estate terms. | Support, custody, property and the household during the separation itself. |
| When it matters | If there is a divorce later, or at a spouse's death for any estate terms. | Right away, while the two of you live apart. |
| Route to a divorce | None on its own. It sets the terms in case a divorce happens. | Once the spouses have lived apart under it for a year, it can serve as the ground for a divorce. |
| Signing rules | Written, signed by both spouses, acknowledged like a deed. | The same. |
Under Domestic Relations Law 236(B)(3), an agreement made during the marriage is valid in a divorce only when the first two requirements below are met. The last two are not written into that section, but they are what make an agreement hard to attack later.
Short answers to what spouses ask most when a postnup first comes up. The details of your own agreement are worth going through with Beth.
Yes, when it is in writing, signed and acknowledged as Domestic Relations Law 236(B)(3) requires. Because courts look closely at agreements between spouses, full disclosure and time to review before signing matter as much as the wording.
You should not. A lawyer can represent only one side of the agreement, so Beth would advise one of you and the other would hire independent counsel. That split protects you both if the agreement is ever questioned.
No. Many couples sign one because they plan to stay married and want a financial question settled so it stops coming up. Most of its terms only come into play if a divorce actually happens.
It can limit or waive maintenance, but New York law sets an outer boundary. Spouses cannot agree to relieve one of them of support in a way that leaves that spouse unable to support themselves and likely to need public assistance.
Bring recent tax returns, statements for bank, retirement and investment accounts, a list of debts, and any prenup or separation agreement you already signed. The office is on Commack Road in Deer Park, and same-day walk-ins are welcome.
Tell Beth what prompted the idea. She will explain what the agreement can do for your marriage, what your spouse's lawyer is likely to raise, and how drafting and negotiation would work.
Call the Deer Park office or request a consultation. You speak directly with Beth, and payment plans are available.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The information on this website is general and is not legal advice for any particular situation. Contacting the office through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship.